- Library Home /
- Search Collections /
- Open Collections /
- Browse Collections /
- UBC Theses and Dissertations /
- Individuality in John Locke and John Stuart Mill: a...
Open Collections
UBC Theses and Dissertations
UBC Theses and Dissertations
Individuality in John Locke and John Stuart Mill: a response to Michael J. Sandel Camcastle, Cara
Abstract
This thesis examines from a philosophical and theoretical standpoint, the validity of the communitarian claim that liberalism promotes an abstract, asocial, and atomistic conception of the self. To better understand the inner logic of Lockean and Millian arguments, I analyse 'individuality' the concept at the centre of the dispute between liberals and communitarians. The thesis illustrates the essentially contested nature of this concept, and the complexity and diversity of the liberal tradition which has been generally overlooked by communitarian critics. Locke's conception of individuality is morphological because it emphasises how an individual assisted by the right kind of education constructs his individuality through deliberation and self-control. In contrast to Sandel's self which cannot distance itself from its obligations and situations, Locke's individual is aware of and assisted by his constitutive attachments but can stand apart from them and critically evaluate them. Reflecting in part the influence of the German Romantics, Mill's conception of individuality is holistic as it strives for completeness of character. In comparison to the static depiction of the self in the liberal-communitarian debate, his conception involves spontaneous development of the individual's unique potential. Communitarians assert that the liberal emphasis on plurality and liberty comes at the expense of securing a conception of the good. Liberty enhances for Locke and Mill the sincerity of beliefs and the authenticity of opinions. Their conceptions of individuality are instrumental in the flourishing of society and are intrinsic to human excellence and virtue. A recognition of the distinctiveness and diversity of human existence facilitates greater social harmony and cooperation.
Item Metadata
Title |
Individuality in John Locke and John Stuart Mill: a response to Michael J. Sandel
|
Creator | |
Publisher |
University of British Columbia
|
Date Issued |
1998
|
Description |
This thesis examines from a philosophical and theoretical standpoint, the validity of
the communitarian claim that liberalism promotes an abstract, asocial, and atomistic
conception of the self. To better understand the inner logic of Lockean and Millian
arguments, I analyse 'individuality' the concept at the centre of the dispute between
liberals and communitarians. The thesis illustrates the essentially contested nature of this
concept, and the complexity and diversity of the liberal tradition which has been
generally overlooked by communitarian critics.
Locke's conception of individuality is morphological because it emphasises how an
individual assisted by the right kind of education constructs his individuality through
deliberation and self-control. In contrast to Sandel's self which cannot distance itself
from its obligations and situations, Locke's individual is aware of and assisted by his
constitutive attachments but can stand apart from them and critically evaluate them.
Reflecting in part the influence of the German Romantics, Mill's conception of
individuality is holistic as it strives for completeness of character. In comparison to the
static depiction of the self in the liberal-communitarian debate, his conception involves
spontaneous development of the individual's unique potential.
Communitarians assert that the liberal emphasis on plurality and liberty comes at the
expense of securing a conception of the good. Liberty enhances for Locke and Mill the
sincerity of beliefs and the authenticity of opinions. Their conceptions of individuality
are instrumental in the flourishing of society and are intrinsic to human excellence and
virtue. A recognition of the distinctiveness and diversity of human existence facilitates
greater social harmony and cooperation.
|
Extent |
4623481 bytes
|
Genre | |
Type | |
File Format |
application/pdf
|
Language |
eng
|
Date Available |
2009-05-20
|
Provider |
Vancouver : University of British Columbia Library
|
Rights |
For non-commercial purposes only, such as research, private study and education. Additional conditions apply, see Terms of Use https://open.library.ubc.ca/terms_of_use.
|
DOI |
10.14288/1.0099242
|
URI | |
Degree | |
Program | |
Affiliation | |
Degree Grantor |
University of British Columbia
|
Graduation Date |
1998-11
|
Campus | |
Scholarly Level |
Graduate
|
Aggregated Source Repository |
DSpace
|
Item Media
Item Citations and Data
Rights
For non-commercial purposes only, such as research, private study and education. Additional conditions apply, see Terms of Use https://open.library.ubc.ca/terms_of_use.